Magnolia Community pulls show immediately after Utah householders open up about renovation nightmares

Designer Candis Meredith, left home owner Aubry Bennion, heart and Andy Meredith are pictured on Bennion’s porch at her Bountiful household in this undated image all through her renovation in which she contracted the Merediths to oversee the do the job. (Aubry Bennion)

Estimated examine time: 7-8 minutes

BOUNTIFUL — When Aubry Bennion’s kitchen renovation method began in October 2019, she had substantial hopes. It was the very last large undertaking in her Bountiful house, which she ordered a calendar year earlier.

Bennion was explained to the renovation, which would be captured on movie for a television present, would very last a couple months and value all around $20,000.

Nonetheless, she explained people hopes quickly gave way to tension, anxiousness and bigger expenses.

Bennion is one of a handful of Utah people talking out on social media and sharing how Candis and Andy Meredith, a Utah couple guiding the television present “Dwelling Operate,” left them hanging. The present was set to debut as component of the new Magnolia Network, the brainchild of “Fixer Higher” stars Chip and Joanna Gaines, which officially released on Wednesday.

Magnolia Community president Allison Web site announced on Friday that the network was eliminating the display from their lineup.

“Magnolia Network is knowledgeable that selected householders have expressed fears about renovation projects carried out by Candis and Andy Meredith,” Web site said. “Inside of the last day, we have discovered extra info about the scope of these problems, and we have determined to get rid of ‘Home Work’ from the Magnolia Network lineup pending a review of the statements that have been built.”

The demonstrate by no means aired on Magnolia Community, according to the company’s Tv set schedule, however, it seems episodes have been readily available to stream by way of the Discovery+ assistance. As of Friday, a world-wide-web webpage with information on the present had been eradicated from Magnolia Network’s internet site. Prior to its elimination, 13 episodes of the Television set show ended up available for streaming.

Despite the Magnolia Network’s makes an attempt to scrub their pages of the present, a article on Instagram featuring the Merediths was however energetic as of Friday. The publish — which attributes the Merediths in the Sanpete County property they renovated as part of the exhibit — has numerous reviews from men and women who assistance Bennion and many others who have also advised their property renovation stories on social media.

How it began

Bennion experienced recognized the Merediths for a couple a long time right after assembly them at a Diy Network start occasion, and the 3 stayed in call more than the several years Immediately after Bennion purchased her Bountiful home, she explained to KSL.com the concept of the 3 collaborating on a job was a no-brainer, particularly with the prospect of the television sequence.

Bountiful resident Aubry Bennion explains the potential changes to her kitchen in a 2019 video sent to Candis and Andy Meredith prior to their renovation.
Bountiful resident Aubry Bennion describes the potential alterations to her kitchen in a 2019 movie sent to Candis and Andy Meredith prior to their renovation. (Photograph: Aubry Bennion)

When they satisfied to explore the project, Bennion reported she nervous that a comprehensive kitchen renovation would expense close to $50,000 — a price tag she could not find the money for. Nevertheless, she claimed she was reassured it would charge a lot significantly less.

“Candis said, ‘Oh gosh, we can do it for 20 (thousand),'” Bennion instructed KSL.com. “In my wildest desire it did not seem doable for $20,000.”

Candis Meredith had been purchasing and renovating houses because she was a younger adult. She later satisfied and married Andrew Meredith and the two worked with each other on various projects, which includes the HGTV system, “Old House Appreciate,” which was debuted in 2015. At that position, the pair explained to Folks magazine in Oct they did not feel they’d ever do Television set again.

That was in advance of the Magnolia Network attained out with a new plan to host a new variation, commencing with the Merediths’ renovation of a 20,000 square-foot schoolhouse into a household for their large, blended family members, as well as renovations for other Utah family members.

The thought that Magnolia was behind it excited quite a few of the show’s future owners, such as Bennion. She even puzzled if the addition of television money meant unique perks like a cost crack or totally free labor, but the price appeared like a offer as well excellent to move up. She mentioned she was advised the gutting and rework would past 3 weeks, starting in Oct 2019, so the job went in advance with a spending budget of $25,000.

Nonetheless, design persisted as a result of March.

Bennion stated there had been lengthy stretches of time without having function remaining done on her kitchen or listening to updates from the Merediths. She obtained a financial institution transfer ask for Thanksgiving early morning in 2019, for 50 percent the meant funds — $13,000. She happily paid the request, she claimed, as it was the to start with time the Merediths had asked. Bennion mentioned she afterwards acquired that the couple had created the ask for from their vacation place in Paris. She expressed she experienced also been annoyed that the rework was in its sixth week, nevertheless only a handful of functioning times were expended in her property.

At one issue, Bennion said the Merediths proposed an plan to knock out a window for a door top to a brand name new deck in her backyard, whilst also relocating an egress window in close proximity to her back door. Bennion’s to start with issue was about the rate, and she was confident it was in just the budget. She eventually approved the deck, but the suggestion finished up decreasing her home worth, she claimed, and would need a high priced take care of.

She later on uncovered that the deck was designed on best of current sod and sprinklers in November. When spring rolled all over, and she almost avoided flooding in her basement, Bennion saw that the design crews had altered the leveling of her property. Correcting the drainage issue, she reported, would in the end cost her $18,000 — extended after the renovation crews ended up gone.

Just after a late crunch to complete her kitchen area, design crews designed the kitchen camera-completely ready, even though, much more operate was needed to make the kitchen purposeful. The previous day of filming was the previous time Bennion spoke with Candis Meredith in human being, she mentioned. The footage of Bennion’s household would stop up not staying utilized.

Months following the development was finished, there ended up continue to more expenses. A flooring corporation told Bennion that they tried using to speak to the Merediths about an unpaid flooring bill, and the last alternative they experienced offered was to place a lien on Bennion’s house. So, she paid out the bill.

In the conclude, Bennion only paid out the Merediths the $13,000, but the fixes to her property far exceeded her formerly set up spending plan of $25,000. She also procured her own appliances for the renovation, which price close to $6,000.

Amid the scrutiny, Candis and Andy Meredith took to social media Friday to protect by themselves. The pair denied defrauding shoppers and mentioned they have normally compensated superb balances.

“Viewing a solitary-sided narrative unfold and these hateful comments from claimed narrative is particularly distressing,” the pair wrote. “We have usually performed what we could to cure anything at all in just and exterior our control.”

Candis Meredith spoke with KSL’s Matt Gephardt on the allegations designed about their function, and conceded that they took on too a lot of jobs at at the time. She also reported they bought many issues out of their very own pockets, and attempted to suitable any completely wrong that she and Andy Meredith knew about.

“We had been feeling pretty overwhelmed and carrying out our most effective to converse, but I can have an understanding of how, when it can be your home, that feels aggravating when points get for a longer time,” she mentioned.

Through this experience, Candis Meredith explained she and her partner have no options to do the job for clientele in the long run.

“I will say we had been naïve about the interior workings of it all, but we’ve spoken with the condition and what we can do, what we could have and could not have carried out, and we have very a great deal realized that was walking a line,” she stated.

It was time

Bennion has been silent about her house renovation concerns for just about two a long time, but determined to share her tale now for the reason that of the Magnolia Network start and the spotlight remaining put on the Merediths.

“I share it due to the fact just after two yrs, they are being celebrated and promoted whilst the folks they harm alongside the way have gotten nowhere,” Bennion wrote on Instagram. “And, on the eve of a Magnolia Community cable launch, the perfectly-edited edition of the tale will exhibit only their side of Oct 2019 and over and above.”

“People today, bank accounts, livelihoods, families, our wellness, sanity … all of us have been left on the cutting area floor,” Bennion reported in a Thursday Instagram submit.

Because she shared her tale on social media earlier this week, many far more house owners in Utah have documented identical, tumultuous ordeals with the Merediths and the prospects of the Property Perform exhibit. Numerous had the identical issues with their spending budget not earning ends fulfill, shoddy workmanship and unfinished issues. One particular loved ones stated they were advised by the Merediths to double their renovation spending plan in get to complete the project.

The developing tale has been picked up by national news corporations, which include the These days Show and Insider, between other individuals, as renovation and do-it-on your own courses on Television set have extended been common with property owners, specifically involving Chip and Joanna Gaines. Though, other than for their Magnolia Community signing the Household Operate display, the Gaines few had very little to do with the Utah enterprise.

Photographs

Related One-way links

Much more tales you may well be interested in